Ugh! This is disgusting! There was a time a very LONG TIME ago when I worked for Chanel as a make up artist. I contracted viral meningitis from a lipstick at the counter that was a tester. It was a tester and I scraped product from the side of the lipstick and I still got sick. Up until,today I have been a HUGE fan of Ulta and bought a lot of cosmetics from them this holiday season for my daughter. This is so unsanitary. Unprofessional. It’s not like they can’t afford to trash their damages. They should be shut down.